Although the gameplay of SuperStar Soccer emphasizes joystick dexterity, there are many bits of realism that add tremendous depth and longevity. For example, putting an older player in the game too early may tire him out for the late game when you really need his expertise, and choosing the COVER defensive strategy will make all your teammates play tight man-to-man coverage. And when it gets right down to pitch action, SuperStar Soccer has it in spades: it deserves to go down in history as the first soccer game ever to implement bicycle kicks and headers in fluid, convincing motion that isn't impossible to execute. Besides these impressive moves, the game allows a surprising range of moves with intuitive joystick controls: you can do a quick shot, speed up to catch the ball (if your power rating is above zero), and leap as a goalie to make a save. One very innovative feature is the indicator bar that shows which side of the goal your shot will travel – a very nice feature that hasn't been seen since. Playing rough may also earn you a penalty, and your player is susceptible to injury if he bumps into an opponent too many times.

With the ability to recruit and trade players, as well as training your team, the only thing SuperStar Soccer doesn't include is actual team names. But don't let that discourage you – the game packs more than enough features and fun to occupy soccer fans with the fictional SporTime league for hours on end. A stellar achievement, especially considering its age. Highly recommended.